Today's mascara 'before & after' is L'Oréal's Volume Million Lashes in Extra Black. I got this as a freebie but I can't remember where from I'm afraid. I haven't worn it much yet but it is quite nice. It is not as heavy as some of the other mascaras that I like and seems to be fairly good at lengthening and separating.
Score chart currently goes something like this -
First Place - ModelCo Fibre Lash Brush on False Lashes
Second Place - Maybelline One by One Volum' Express Satin Black
Third Place - Benefit They're Real!
Fourth Place - L'Oréal's Volume Million Lashes in Extra Black
Fifth Place - Revlon Grow Luscious by Fabulash because it actually looks quite nice in the pictures.
Sixth Place - Maybelline's XXL PRO Extensions.
Seventh Place - Maybelline's The Falsies Volum' Express
Although the longer this list gets the harder it is to choose which ones are better than others.